Who: MM (52, Aquarius, Divorced, 2 Kids, Published Writer, Drummer, tall, slim, nice eyes, dark and intense personality)
Where: 10pm, Sunset Park (his house)
I am fucking Daddy in the ass with a toy. He is laying on his back, on the couch- legs splayed and up in the air. “Talk to me…” he said, as I massage his hole and insert the tip of the toy in slowly and deliberately.
“Daddy’s a nasty bitch” I whisper, “Daddy’s such a filthy ass slut, taking his toy and liking it.” Daddy moans as I simultaneously probe his ass and give him a handjob. “Take it Daddy, ” I continue, “You’ve been very bad and you deserve to be PUNISHED.” I try to not let my voice crack in nervousness or laughter. This is a first for both of us. How the fuck did I get here?!?
11 months ago: I matched with MM on Tinder. At 50, he was a little past my age range (I generally go for 38-48). But something about his photos drew me in- he had a kind face and a shy smile, most of his photos showed him smiling and squinting into the camera. His profile was sparse, it only said “Writer.”
“Hello,” he wrote, “How’s your day going? I noticed you play bass! That is way cool. I used to play drums for an Indie band.”
I had been wandering around Williamsburg enjoying the mid-August weather and I sat down at a cafe to chat with him. “Hi!” I responded, “Yes I play bass for a few bands. You’re a writer? What kind of stuff do you write?”
We chatted for most of the day and I found out he had several novels that were published that were in the thriller/suspense genre. Unbeknownst to him, I found a few excerpts of his book and read a handful of reviews. “Really fucked up.” One reviewer wrote. “Ugh,” another reviewer commented, “Really creepy.. I couldn’t sleep after reading this book.”
My eyes widened, “Hey,” I typed, “Want to grab a drink sometime?”
3 days later, 7pm: I’m walking through midtown Manhattan on my way to meet MM at an Irish pub to watch the Mayweather/McGregor Boxing match. (I’m a huge MMA fan and was obsessed with McGregor at that time, and the McGregor/Mayweather match was historic. Connor McGregor, who is an MMA fighter, was crossing over into boxing to compete against Floyd Mayweather, Jr. who was coming out of retirement for this one fight.) We decided on this low-key Irish Pub on the west side. “Hey,” MM texted, “I’m inside, downstairs, in the back… I got us table seats.” I nervously touched up my make-up, took a deep breath, and walked in.
The first thing I noticed was how tall MM was. He stood up when he saw me and gave me the seat next to him (The bar was packed for this event, and we were sharing the table with a very nice Cuban couple who was rooting for Mayweather.)
“Hi..” he said, as I sat down. He offered his hand- I shook it, then looked up. Oh holy shit.. this guy is a man, like a real adult man in the wild. I had mostly gone on dates with 40 year old hipster man-children who lived like they were in their 20’s, free from any responsibility, drinking happy hour $3 beers, living with IKEA furniture and 3 roommates in some overcrowded, overpriced apartment in Williamsburg.
MM looked like he had responsibilities- and of course he did, he had two daughters to raise. “Hi,” I said nervously, “Nice to finally meet you.” We ordered our drinks (Guinness and a shot of whiskey) and proceeded to spend the next 6 hours drinking, chatting and waiting for the goddamn main card to start. (We didn’t realize there were pre-fights before the main fight and the main event started well after midnight.)
MM is a good conversationalist. I’ve never had anyone ask me so many questions and really listen. I think because he’s a writer, so he’s very curious about people. Throughout the fight, we exchanged stories, talked music, talked shit. I was having fun. Sometime around the 5th drink, I began wondering what it would be like to kiss him. Fuck.. I wonder if he likes me. Ugh, he hasn’t really done anything to let me know he’s interested. Wait, I think he did touch my back when he came back from the bathroom to sit back down, but maybe it was a mistake? Need to think fast.. the fight is almost over!!
I leaned in slowly while we were talking. He seemed unfazed. Fuck. Fuck!!! Ok drastic measures. I gently put my feet on the lower edge of his chair while facing him. 1/2 hour later the fight was done. One last whiskey shot, a little tipsy we headed out.
I’m walking with MM toward my train on 34th street and we’re silent. I’m still not sure if he’s even remotely interested in me, but at this point I don’t give a fuck anymore. It’s 2 am and I’m tired. “Ok,” I said as I stop in front of my station, “I’m taking this train- it was nice to meet you and hang out.. I’m bummed McGregor lost, but at least he fought a good fight.”
“Yea maybe he’ll win the next one.” MM said looking down. Awkward pause. Oh shit, oh shit.. what do I do?!?!?!? I don’t know what came over me, perhaps it was the last whiskey shot, perhaps it was watching all the blood and gore of the boxing match, but I leaned in and just kissed him. We stood there for a few minutes kissing and MM pulled away. He grinned with his eyes squinty… “I’m staying uptown tonight, do you want to come over?” I hesitated.
“No, it’s ok..” I said, turning away. “Have a good night.” I walked down the stairs, not looking back. I just left him standing there.
MM never called me back and I never expected him to. It’s ok, I thought, he seemed really, really boring and vanilla anyways- and wayyyyy too old for me. I tried to console myself. I pushed that date out of my mind and forgot about him. I forgot, until he texted me 6 months later out of the blue.
“Hey it’s me- MM, remember me?”
(…to be continued)